Macro & Investment Insights

Fiscal Forward Guidance

  • 30 November 2020
  • 5min read

Key points

  • The current EU fiscal surveillance framework is probably ill-suited to guide governments through their “exit strategy” from the ongoing extraordinary policy stimulus. We explore some solutions.
  • For all the drama, even with a Free Trade Agreement agreed in the next few days, the UK will have chosen one of the most aggressive options which were available post-Brexit to shape its relationship with the EU.

We explore this week the possible “exit strategy” from the ongoing extraordinary fiscal and monetary stimulus. Drawing on Olivier Blanchard’ recent research, we argue that the current EU fiscal surveillance framework may be ill-suited to guide governments through an optimal path for a fiscal consolidation which would ensure public debt sustainability while preserving the economic recovery. However, Blanchard’s favoured solutions – moving to a discretionary assessment by the Commission with strong enforcement power or using the ECB’s existing OMT framework – do not seem politically feasible to us, at least not without going first through a painful phase of volatility and tension on sovereign spreads. We continue to think that voluntary “fiscal forward guidance”, i.e. ex ante commitments by governments to start tightening fiscal policy once certain numerical thresholds are met on the recovery (e.g. unemployment falling below a pre-set level) would offer enough visibility for the ECB to map their own normalization while minimizing the risks of market turmoil. There is no perfect system, if only because fiscal policy remains essentially the product of democratic decisions while monetary policy is a technocratic one, and we would expect quite a lot of noise on the route to exit, but the conversation at the institutional level needs to start before the pandemic emergency is over.

Meanwhile, as we write a deal has yet to be agreed between the UK and the EU. For all the drama around this “race against time” to provide some organized framework around the UK/EU economic relationship, the low-quality Free Trade Agreement which is being painfully negotiated would still be one of the worst arrangements among all those which were thinkable after Brexit. An FTA will be far from providing “frictionless trade” between the EU and the UK, which was the British government’s initial objective immediately after the referendum. It would obviously be better for the UK – and to a lesser extent the EU – if a deal was struck, to avoid customs tariff being slapped (the extension of the UK tariffs on food imported to the UK could raise the overall consumer price level by 0.5% immediately), but even with an FTA the damage will be significant. We remain baffled that the negotiation is still hinging on fishing, which contributes 0.1% to the British GDP, while any attempt to secure the position of the UK financial services in the EU has been abandoned months ago (this industry contributes about 10%). Politics has its reasons, and its economic costs.

    Not for Retail distribution

    This document is intended exclusively for Professional, Institutional, Qualified or Wholesale Clients / Investors only, as defined by applicable local laws and regulation. Circulation must be restricted accordingly.

    This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment research or financial analysis relating to transactions in financial instruments as per MIF Directive (2014/65/EU), nor does it constitute on the part of AXA Investment Managers or its affiliated companies an offer to buy or sell any investments, products or services, and should not be considered as solicitation or investment, legal or tax advice, a recommendation for an investment strategy or a personalized recommendation to buy or sell securities.

    It has been established on the basis of data, projections, forecasts, anticipations and hypothesis which are subjective. Its analysis and conclusions are the expression of an opinion, based on available data at a specific date.
    All information in this document is established on data made public by official providers of economic and market statistics. AXA Investment Managers disclaims any and all liability relating to a decision based on or for reliance on this document. All exhibits included in this document, unless stated otherwise, are as of the publication date of this document. Furthermore, due to the subjective nature of these opinions and analysis, these data, projections, forecasts, anticipations, hypothesis, etc. are not necessary used or followed by AXA IM’s portfolio management teams or its affiliates, who may act based on their own opinions. Any reproduction of this information, in whole or in part is, unless otherwise authorised by AXA IM, prohibited.

    Issued in the UK by AXA Investment Managers UK Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the UK. Registered in England and Wales, No: 01431068. Registered Office: 22 Bishopsgate, London, EC2N 4BQ. In other jurisdictions, this document is issued by AXA Investment Managers SA’s affiliates in those countries.