Machine learning and factor investing
- Machine learning has the power to uncover previously inaccessible investment insights
- These insights can be of particular benefit to factor investors, where sophisticated data integration and analysis is already a key element of the investment process
- Neural networks help us to ensure our portfolios continue to learn from dynamic and evolving markets
“Make the most of your regrets…” Henry David Thoreau
‘No regrets’ is a great philosophy for life that sadly has little application to investing. Even successful factor investors – systematically investing in strategies with proven long-term track records – can look back on market-beating returns and still find several stocks that failed to meet their expectations over part, or even all, of their holding period.
Fortunately, while investors have no choice whether to face regrets, they can decide what to do with them. In our more than 30 years of experience, Rosenberg Equities has learned a great deal about the elements that influence a stock’s ability to live up to its factor profile. Our active approach is designed to feed these lessons back into our investment process. Intelligent diversification, multi-factor investing, and contextual modelling are core aspects of our process that have evolved out of this research; in recent years, advances in machine learning have added another important item to our toolkit, helping us to ensure our portfolios continue to incorporate insights from constantly evolving markets.
Machine learning in factor portfolios
Machine learning is a form of artificial intelligence in which computer models learn from past data to make predictions with minimal human intervention. Given the dramatic increase in computing power and data availability in the past decade, this type of analysis is being applied to an ever-wider range of problems, including in the world of finance. For us, one of its most exciting contributions is as a complement to our existing factor models, aimed at unearthing the complex interactions between the fundamental drivers of equity market risk and return.
Machine learning’s ability to uncover non-linear relationships between variables is particularly valuable. Traditional factor strategies assume linearity: Lower price-to-earnings multiples, higher historical returns on equity and stronger recent price momentum all translate into higher expected returns – in a straight line. While these and other simple factor insights work on average – and are rewarded more reliably over long than short time horizons – their simplicity inevitably creates blind spots.
Common sense tells us that the world is not always quite so straightforward and that a more nuanced assessment can potentially help to construct better factors. Machine learning provides new, and powerful, ways to implement this intuition in portfolios.
Machine learning and time travel: Bringing regrets forward
Our factor strategies are designed to achieve a wide range of investor objectives. In risk reduction strategies, we emphasize the low volatility and quality factors, while in portfolios designed to generate higher returns, we blend quality, momentum and value to identify companies with robust fundamentals that are priced too cheaply.
Both sets of combinations have consistently achieved their risk and return objectives in live portfolios. They have also delivered the fundamental outcomes that we believe account for their long-term success: Higher and less volatile earnings growth and yields than the market.
Of course, these well diversified strategies also have something else in common: Companies that, for whatever reason, don’t deliver the outcomes we expect! Machine learning enables us to analyse these surprises in more detail than before, to study their characteristics through time, and to use this information to identify stocks that may appear attractive to our models today but are at particular risk of disappointment. Instead of suffering the pangs of regret after the fact, we seek to bring them forward to before our investment decision, with the goal of improving stock selection.
To do this, we use a supervised artificial neural network that we have trained to recognise companies at risk of short-term distress. The model learns to identify these firms by identifying patterns among the stocks in a historical dataset that went on to suffer higher-than-average year-ahead volatility. These companies are clearly unsuitable candidates for a low-risk portfolio and are typically unnecessary, or even unhelpful, additions to return-seeking strategies. Indeed, long-term analysis suggests that reducing the weight of these stocks in our portfolios can potentially meaningfully improve the performance of both low volatility and value-oriented strategies. In our tests, machine learning techniques have proven to be more effective at identifying these stocks than traditional linear methods based on historical risk (as shown in Exhibit 1, below).
Exhibit 1: Our machine-learned model has generated consistently more accurate forecasts than traditional models
Source: Rosenberg Equities, data as of 31 July, 2020. Chart shows rolling 12-month forward hit rates, a measure of model efficacy, for a range of factors designed to forecast the year-ahead volatility of stocks in the MSCI World Index each month since 2016. Traditional volatility forecasts are based on stocks’ trailing 5-year and 1-year standard deviation of returns. Dates of implementation of our machine learned forecasts in actual client portfolios vary across strategies, starting in 2017. This is not a real-time capture of Rosenberg Equities’ machine learned forecast forward hit rates during the timeframe shown, but a recreation of the data using Rosenberg Equities’ current machine learned forecast model as applied to historical data. Forward hit rates of any kind, especially those generated with the benefit of hindsight, are no guarantee that Rosenberg Equities will achieve outperformance.
How does the model work?
Neural networks are made up of interconnected sets of inputs (nodes) that can be trained to model relationships in a similar way that certain biological systems, such as the brain, process information.
Data scientists have discretion over both the number and nature of the inputs they use in their neural networks. In our model, we emphasise parsimoniousness and economic intuition, using about a dozen variables with which we have extensive research experience and which we believe can provide clues about a company’s underlying performance. These include measures of quality, valuation and volatility, such as models of potential asset impairment, default risk and dividend cut, price to book and earnings ratios, and short-term share turnover, as well as price momentum and fluctuations.
Exhibit 2: The structure and output of the model
In simple terms, the model assesses each input variable’s effect on future volatility, then evaluates this with reference to all of the other attributes to construct a multi-dimensional perspective that accounts for the interactions between variables. The graphic above gives a sense of the model’s general structure and output. The “input layer” on the left contains the predictor variable values. These values are passed to the second column – called a hidden layer – with varying weights depending on the predictive power of each (represented by the colours of the connecting lines). Each node in the hidden layer is a separate logistic regression with its own blend of weights on the input variables. Calculations from the hidden layer are then blended with various weights to generate the output layer (the final column), which contains the probability that a stock will become high or low risk.
The non-linear output of the model is shown on the right-hand side of the chart. Distinct from the simple factor insights mentioned above (which would show diagonal bands of colour in the grid), our model reveals a more complex topography of potential regrets. Stocks that the model locates in these areas can either be excluded or down weighted in our investment process.
Overcoming regret aversion
Behavioural economics tells us that investors typically do a bad job of dealing with regret. When not carefully managed, their “regret aversion” can lead to indecision or to unhelpful deviation from sensible long-term investment strategies.
Factor investing may be particularly susceptible to this. While decades of data support the long-term effectiveness of these strategies, at some point all experience periods of underperformance. What’s more, even outperforming portfolios will inevitably hold stocks that trail the market, or fail to hold those that strongly beat it, over time. The recent high-profile outperformance of certain stocks with weak factor footprints has demonstrated this point clearly.
We have strong conviction in the insights that drive our factor strategies. Nonetheless, we believe that studying the stocks that fail to live up to our expectations and systematically incorporating this information into our investment process offers an important opportunity to improve their long-term performance. Machine learning techniques can make particularly compelling contributions in this area, adding considerable analytical power as well as opening up previously illusive non-linearities. While these techniques won’t remove regrets from our portfolios, we believe that they will play a key role in helping us to make the most of them.
 See Annie Duke, “Thinking in Bets: Making Smarter Decisions When You Don’t Have All the Facts”, 2018
 Past performance is no guide to future performance.
This communication is for professional/institutional investors only and must not be relied upon by retail investors. Any reproduction/redistribution of this information is prohibited.
This material is published for informational purposes only and is neither an offer to enter into, or a term or condition of any business or agreement with the recipient or any other party, nor is it a solicitation for any services, securities, or funds herein, nor is it intended to provide investment, tax, or legal advice. If this material refers to funds, investments made therein are subject to the relevant fund documents. This material is not intended for distribution to persons or in jurisdictions where prohibited. No representation is made that any of the services, securities, or funds herein are suitable for any particular investor, and therefore, any prospective investor should consult their financial or other advisors about the appropriateness thereof. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this material. Investments may decrease in value and that past or backtested performance is no guide to future performance. Forward-looking or simulated data or information herein are subject to inherent limitations and are based upon assumptions that may not materialize, and may vary significantly from actual results. Investment models, research, and risk controls described herein do not guarantee against loss of principal or that any investment objectives shown herein will be achieved. The data, projections, forecasts, anticipations, hypotheses and/or opinions herein are subjective, and are not necessarily used or followed by the firm or its affiliates who may act based on their own opinions and as independent departments or entities within the organization. This information is always subject to change and all rights are reserved thereof. Performance shown, unless otherwise stated, is gross of management fees. An investor’s actual return will be reduced by management fees and other expenses the investor may incur.
The firm seeks to achieve its clients’ investment objectives primarily through reliance on the modelling of proprietary and 3rd party financial and non-financial data, information, and considerations, the sources, weights, and implementation of which may be subject to change and/or the discretion of the firm regardless of whether described herein or elsewhere. Although many of its investment approaches are driven by bottom-up stock selection akin to that of a traditional fundamental investor, the firm seeks to achieve its clients’ investment objectives primarily in reliance on analytical models. The goal of the firm’s systematic approach is not to replicate a perfect “model” portfolio; instead, like other long-term, fundamentally oriented investors, it seeks to create portfolios possessing ex ante those fundamental and statistically important characteristics reflecting our investment beliefs. The firm’s ability to implement its investment objectives depends on various considerations such as the models’ economic, analytical and mathematical underpinnings, the accurate encapsulation of those principles in a complex computational (including software code) environment, the quality of the models’ data inputs, changes in market conditions, and the successful expression of the models' views into the investment portfolio construction process. Many of these have subjective elements that present the possibility of human error. While the investment process principally relies on models, the firm’s process also incorporates the investment judgment of its portfolio managers who may exercise discretion in attempting to capture the intent of the models, particularly in changing market conditions. The firm’s success in implementing its investment objectives may depend on the ability of portfolio managers and others to interpret and implement the signals generated by the models. The firm has established certain systematic rules and processes for monitoring client portfolios to ensure that they are managed in accordance with their investment objectives, but there is no guarantee that these rules or processes will effectively manage the risks associated with its investment process under all market conditions. While the firm employs controls designed to assure that our models are sound in their development and appropriately adapted, calibrated and configured, analytical error, software development errors, and implementation errors are an inherent risk of complex analytical models and quantitative investment management processes. These errors may be extremely hard to detect, and some may go undetected for long periods of time or indefinitely. The firm’s controls, including our escalation policies, are designed to ensure that certain types of errors are subject to review once discovered. However, the effect of errors on our investment process and, where relevant, performance (which can be either positive or negative) may not be fully apparent even when discovered. When the firm discovers an investment process error in one of its models, it may in good faith and in accordance with its obligations, decide not to correct the error, to delay correction of an error, or develop other methodology to address the error, if not inconsistent with the client’s interests. Also, the firm generally will not disclose to affected clients investment process errors that are not the result of a contractual or regulatory breach, or that are non-compensable, unless it otherwise determines that information regarding the error is material to its clients.
If MSCI information appears herein, it may only be used for your internal use, it may not be reproduced or re-disseminated in any form, and it may not be used as a basis for, or a component of, any financial instruments or products or indices. None of the MSCI information is intended to constitute investment advice or a recommendation to make (or refrain from making) any kind of investment decision and may not be relied on as such. Historical data and analysis should not be taken as an indication or guarantee of any future performance analysis, forecast or prediction. The MSCI information is provided on an “as is” basis and the user of this information assumes the entire risk of any use made of this information. MSCI, each of its affiliates and each other person involved in or related to compiling, computing or creating any MSCI information (collectively, the “MSCI Parties”) expressly disclaims all warranties (including, without limitation, any warranties of originality, accuracy, completeness, timeliness, non-infringement, merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose) with respect to this information. Without limiting any of the foregoing, in no event shall any MSCI Party have any liability for any direct, indirect, special, incidental, punitive, consequential (including, without limitation, lost profits) or any other damages. (www.mscibarra.com).
Certain ESG data provided by and/or calculated using Trucost data. Trucost reserves all intellectual and other proprietary rights in Trucost data.
Issued in the U.K. by AXA Investment Managers UK Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the U.K. Registered in England and Wales, No: 01431068. Registered Office: 155 Bishopsgate, London, EC2M 3YD (until 31st December 2020); 22 Bishopsgate, London, EC2N 4BQ (from 1st January 2021).
©2020 AXA Investment Managers. All rights reserved.
Please note that references to “Rosenberg Equities” herein refer solely to an expertise of AXA Investment Managers and not a specific legal entity. These materials are issued by the relevant AXA Investment Managers legal entity located in the recipient’s respective jurisdiction or region. Depending on the relevant issuing entity, the following additional disclosures may apply:
For US investors: Within the United States, “Rosenberg Equities” refers to AXA Rosenberg Investment Management LLC, a SEC registered investment adviser. It’s affiliate, AXA Investment Managers Inc. is responsible for sales, distribution, and client service activity on behalf of Rosenberg Equities. Further information on AXA Rosenberg Investment Management LLC’s fees may be found in its Form ADV Part 2 or provided upon request. The collection of management fees produces a compounding effect on the total rate of return net of management fees. As an example, the effect of management fees on the total value of an investor’s portfolio assuming a) quarterly fee assessment, b) $1,000,000 investment, c) portfolio return of 8% a year, and d) 1.00% annual investment management fee would be $10,416 in the first year, and cumulatively $59,816 over five years and $143,430 over ten years.
For Australian investors: AXA Investment Managers Asia (Singapore) Ltd (ARBN 115203622) is exempt from the requirement to hold an Australian Financial Services License and is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore under Singaporean laws, which differ from Australian laws. AXA IM offers financial services in Australia only to residents who are “wholesale clients" within the meaning of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).
For European investors: AXA Investment Managers UK Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the U.K. Registered in England and Wales, No: 01431068. Registered Office: 155 Bishopsgate, London, EC2M 3YD (until 31st December 2020); 22 Bishopsgate, London, EC2N 4BQ (from 1st January 2021). This material is intended for the use of persons meeting the MiFID client classification of Professional Clients or Eligible Counterparties and is not approved for communication to retail customers in any territory. The financial instruments used carry inherent risks which are unavoidable such as Market Risk, Credit Risk, Liquidity Risk and other risks. These risks are described in detail in our Risk Warnings document which is available upon request.
For Hong Kong investors: The authorisation of any fund by the Securities and Futures Commission in Hong Kong (“SFC”) does not imply official approval or recommendation. SFC authorization of a fund is not a recommendation or endorsement of a fund nor does it guarantee the commercial merits of a fund or its performance. It does not mean the fund is suitable for all investors nor is it an endorsement of its suitability for any particular investor or class of investors. Where any of the Funds is not authorized by the SFC, the information contained herein in connection with such unauthorized Fund is solely for the use of professional investors in Hong Kong. Materials exempted from authorization by the SFC have not been reviewed by the SFC
For Japanese Clients: AXA INVESTMENT MANAGERS JAPAN LTD., whose registered office and principal place of business is at NBF Platinum Tower 14F 1-17-3 Shirokane, Minato-ku, Tokyo 108-0072, Japan, which is registered with the Financial Services Agency of Japan under the number KANTOZAIMUKYOKUCHO (KINSHO) 16, and is a member of Japan Securities Dealers Association, Type II Financial Instrument Firms Association, Investment Trust Association of Japan and Japan Investment Advisers Association to carry out the regulated activity of Financial Instrument Business under the Financial Instrument Exchange Law of Japan. In Japan, none of the funds mentioned in this document are registered under the Financial Instrument Exchange Law of Japan or Act on Investment Trusts and Investment Corporations. This document is purely for the information purpose for use by Qualified Institutional Investors defined by the Financial Instrument Exchange Law of Japan.
For Korean investors: In Korea, AXA Investment Managers Asia (Singapore) Ltd is a registered Cross Border Investment Advisor/Discretionary Investment Management Company under the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act (the “Act”). The activities referenced under the Act are 5-2-2 Investment Advisory Business and 6-2-2 Discretionary Investment Management Business, respectively. Its financial services are available in Korea only to Professional Investors within the meaning of Article 10 of Enforcement Decree of the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act.
To the extent that any fund is mentioned in this document, neither the fund nor AXA IM Asia is making any representation with respect to the eligibility of any recipients of this document to acquire the units/shares in the fund under the laws of Korea, including but without limitation the Foreign Exchange Transaction Act and Regulations thereunder. The units/shares have not been registered under the Financial Investment Services and Capital Markets Act of Korea, and none of the units/shares may be offered, sold or delivered, or offered or sold to any person for re-offering or resale, directly or indirectly, in Korea or to any resident of Korea except pursuant to applicable laws and regulations of Korea.
For Singapore investors: In Singapore, this document is issued by AXA Investment Managers Asia (Singapore) Ltd. (Registration No. 199001714W) and is intended for the use of Institutional Investors only as defined in Section 4A of the Securities and Futures Act (Cap. 289) and must not be relied upon by retail investors. Circulation must be restricted accordingly.
For Swiss Investors: For Switzerland this information is intended exclusively for Qualified Investors according to Swiss law. Circulation must be restricted accordingly. The Swiss representative for the Irish-domiciled open-ended Unit Trust AXA Rosenberg Equity Alpha Trust, is First Independent Fund Services Ltd, Klausstrasse 33, CH-8008 Zurich. The Swiss paying agent is BNP Paribas Securities Services, succursale de Zurich, Selnaustrasse 16, CH-8002 Zurich. The current prospectus, the Key Investor Information Document (the ‘KIID’) as well as the annual and semi-annual reports can be obtained free of charge from the Swiss representative. In respect of the units distributed in and from Switzerland, the place of jurisdiction is Zurich, Switzerland.
For Taiwan investors: The offer, distribution, sale or re-sale of fund units/shares in Taiwan requires approval from and/or registration with Taiwanese regulatory authorities. To the extent that any units/shares of the Funds are not so licensed or registered, such units/shares are made available in Taiwan on a private placement basis only to banks, bills houses, trust enterprises, financial holding companies and other qualified entities or institutions (collectively, “Qualified Institutions”) and other entities and individuals meeting specific criteria (“Other Qualified Investors”) pursuant to the private placement provisions of the Rules Governing Offshore Funds. No other offer or sale of such units/shares in Taiwan is permitted. Taiwanese purchasers of such units/shares may not sell or otherwise dispose of their holdings except by redemption, transfer to a Qualified Institution or Other Qualified Investor, transfer by operation of law or other means approved by the Taiwan Financial Supervisory Commission.
For Thailand investors: Nothing in this document shall constitute in any manner whatsoever a proposal to make available, offer for subscription or purchase or to issue an invitation to purchase or subscribe for any securities in Thailand or a proposal to implement any of the foregoing in Thailand nor has this document been approved by or registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Thailand (“SEC”). No person receiving a copy of this document may treat the same as constituting an invitation or offer to him in Thailand and such person shall not distribute or make available this document in Thailand. The issuer of this document shall not be liable in any manner whatsoever in the event this document is distributed or made available to any person in Thailand receiving a copy of this document. Since no application for approval has been or will be made to the SEC for the offering of the securities, or for the registration of this document, the securities shall not be offered for subscription or purchased or made available, whether directly or indirectly, in Thailand. It is the sole responsibility of recipients wishing to take any action upon this document to satisfy themselves as to the full observance of the laws of Thailand, to comply with all relevant government and regulatory approvals, and to comply with all applicable laws, including but not limited to exchange control laws.
Not for Retail distribution: This document is intended exclusively for Professional, Institutional, Qualified or Wholesale Clients / Investors only, as defined by applicable local laws and regulation. Circulation must be restricted accordingly.
This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment research or financial analysis relating to transactions in financial instruments as per MIF Directive (2014/65/EU), nor does it constitute on the part of AXA Investment Managers or its affiliated companies an offer to buy or sell any investments, products or services, and should not be considered as solicitation or investment, legal or tax advice, a recommendation for an investment strategy or a personalized recommendation to buy or sell securities.
Due to its simplification, this document is partial and opinions, estimates and forecasts herein are subjective and subject to change without notice. There is no guarantee forecasts made will come to pass. Data, figures, declarations, analysis, predictions and other information in this document is provided based on our state of knowledge at the time of creation of this document. Whilst every care is taken, no representation or warranty (including liability towards third parties), express or implied, is made as to the accuracy, reliability or completeness of the information contained herein. Reliance upon information in this material is at the sole discretion of the recipient. This material does not contain sufficient information to support an investment decision.
Issued in the U.K. by AXA Investment Managers UK Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the U.K. Registered in England and Wales, No: 01431068. Registered Office: 7 Newgate Street, London, EC1A 7NX (until 3rd September 2020); 155 Bishopsgate, London, EC2M 3YD (until 31st December 2020); 22 Bishopsgate, London, EC2N 4BQ (from 1st January 2021).
In other jurisdictions, this document is issued by AXA Investment Managers SA’s affiliates in those countries.